election-methods@mailman.electorama.com

Technical discussion of election methods

View all threads

British Columbia voting-method reform

V
VoteFair
Sun, Jan 14, 2018 7:09 PM

British Columbia (in Canada) is considering changing their voting
system.  Here is a link to that process:

https://engage.gov.bc.ca/howwevote/

Here is the first paragraph from that page:

"The B.C. Government has introduced legislation to hold a referendum in
the fall of 2018, which will ask British Columbians to decide whether
B.C. should keep its current voting system (First Past the Post) or move
to a system of Proportional Representation. Countries around the world
use different voting systems to elect their representatives. How a
voting system is designed influences how a society is governed."

These are the proposed alternatives:

  • List Proportional Representation (List PR)

  • Single Transferable Vote (STV)

  • Mixed-Member Proportional (MMP)

  • Mixed-Member Majoritarian (MMM) (also called Parallel)

Alas, these alternatives increase control for political-party insiders
in choosing which candidates win seats.  In other words, they compromise
electorate proportionality in order to get party proportionality.

And apparently they are glossing over the important distinction between
open-list PR and closed-list PR.  And some of these alternatives
continue to use single-mark ballots.

I don't have time to get involved in this reform effort, so I'm hoping
that other folks in this forum are interested in helping steer the
decision away from the worst choices.

Richard Fobes

British Columbia (in Canada) is considering changing their voting system. Here is a link to that process: https://engage.gov.bc.ca/howwevote/ Here is the first paragraph from that page: "The B.C. Government has introduced legislation to hold a referendum in the fall of 2018, which will ask British Columbians to decide whether B.C. should keep its current voting system (First Past the Post) or move to a system of Proportional Representation. Countries around the world use different voting systems to elect their representatives. How a voting system is designed influences how a society is governed." These are the proposed alternatives: * List Proportional Representation (List PR) * Single Transferable Vote (STV) * Mixed-Member Proportional (MMP) * Mixed-Member Majoritarian (MMM) (also called Parallel) Alas, these alternatives increase control for political-party insiders in choosing which candidates win seats. In other words, they compromise electorate proportionality in order to get party proportionality. And apparently they are glossing over the important distinction between open-list PR and closed-list PR. And some of these alternatives continue to use single-mark ballots. I don't have time to get involved in this reform effort, so I'm hoping that other folks in this forum are interested in helping steer the decision away from the worst choices. Richard Fobes