Today I told how the B voters can betray in U/P. They can do the same thing in MMPO & ICT: They can rank C over A. ...and thereby win. CD's premise doesn't exclude that. Change CD to condone that? What would be the point? The betrayal would still be there. Maybe there could be a weak CD, but it wouldn't mean much. Michael Ossipoff

Mike, > Today I told how the B voters can betray in U/P. > > They can do the same thing in MMPO & ICT: > > They can rank C over A. ...and thereby win. > I don't see how that is the case under ICT (aka TTR,TR), for example: 34 C 33 A>B 32 B>C (sincere is B>A) C>A 66-33, A>B 33-32, B>C 65-34. TR scores: C34, A33, B32 On no ballots is more than one candidate voted equal-top. No candidate pairwise beats all the others so TTR disqualifies no-one and C has the highest TR score so C wins. MMPO scores: B34, C65, A66. Yes, B has the lowest score and so wins. Chris Benham On 9/21/2016 11:04 AM, Michael Ossipoff wrote: > > Today I told how the B voters can betray in U/P. > > They can do the same thing in MMPO & ICT: > > They can rank C over A. ...and thereby win. > > CD's premise doesn't exclude that. > > Change CD to condone that? What would be the point? The betrayal would > still be there. > > Maybe there could be a weak CD, but it wouldn't mean much. > > Michael Ossipoff > > > > ---- > Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info > > > No virus found in this message. > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com <http://www.avg.com> > Version: 2016.0.7797 / Virus Database: 4656/13054 - Release Date: 09/20/16 >