election-methods@mailman.electorama.com

Technical discussion of election methods

View all threads

Fixing the Voting Criteria WikiTable

CL
Closed Limelike Curves
Tue, Feb 13, 2024 5:30 AM

The voting criteria table on Wikipedia seems to get a lot of hits compared
to other pages about election methods. I'd like to improve on it by adding
more information (including comparisons based on utilitarian/simulation
criteria), and by breaking it into more-readable subcategories that users
can collapse down.

I'm looking for help with adding extra systems and criteria! I've started
by adding everything I could find off of Wikipedia and ElectoWiki, but I'm
sure there's some results I'm missing. I'm extra-interested in information
about honesty criteria (especially regarding cardinal systems).

You can edit the Google Sheet here:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/11KxpITY1h4TrwvL7WKKwowdEHe0ifezV9IBe2leVNi8/edit?usp=sharing

Thanks!

The voting criteria table on Wikipedia seems to get a lot of hits compared to other pages about election methods. I'd like to improve on it by adding more information (including comparisons based on utilitarian/simulation criteria), and by breaking it into more-readable subcategories that users can collapse down. I'm looking for help with adding extra systems and criteria! I've started by adding everything I could find off of Wikipedia and ElectoWiki, but I'm sure there's some results I'm missing. I'm extra-interested in information about honesty criteria (especially regarding cardinal systems). You can edit the Google Sheet here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/11KxpITY1h4TrwvL7WKKwowdEHe0ifezV9IBe2leVNi8/edit?usp=sharing Thanks!