election-methods@mailman.electorama.com

Technical discussion of election methods

View all threads

Slightly modified Approval

EB
Etjon Basha
Wed, Jan 8, 2025 11:18 AM

Good evening gentlemen, and a Happy New Year,

And with the new year, I renew my search for that slight improvement over
approval that fails LnH a bit less but otherwise still retains the method’s
other strengths (ability to be counted by hand chief among these in my
eyes).

So, here’s the nth contestant: voters submit ranked ballots, with
truncation and equal ranking allowed, and all explicitly ranked candidates
considered approved.

You compute the standard approval winner. If they win by less than 50% of
the vote, they are the winner.

Otherwise, truncate all ballots just prior to the standard approval winner
(if multiple candidates share a tier with the approval winner, leave them
on the truncated ballot). Compute the modified approval winner. If they win
by more than 50% of the vote, elect them. Otherwise, elect the standard
approval winner. End.

A slight but material modification of my earlier attempt based on the FPP
winner.

If not already existing in some form, perhaps it may be of some interest.

Best regards,

Etjon

Good evening gentlemen, and a Happy New Year, And with the new year, I renew my search for that slight improvement over approval that fails LnH a bit less but otherwise still retains the method’s other strengths (ability to be counted by hand chief among these in my eyes). So, here’s the nth contestant: voters submit ranked ballots, with truncation and equal ranking allowed, and all explicitly ranked candidates considered approved. You compute the standard approval winner. If they win by less than 50% of the vote, they are the winner. Otherwise, truncate all ballots just prior to the standard approval winner (if multiple candidates share a tier with the approval winner, leave them on the truncated ballot). Compute the modified approval winner. If they win by more than 50% of the vote, elect them. Otherwise, elect the standard approval winner. End. A slight but material modification of my earlier attempt based on the FPP winner. If not already existing in some form, perhaps it may be of some interest. Best regards, Etjon