I suspect that a Condorcet method exists (e.g. any ISDA method)
which can only fail participation when the winner is not the
first Smith-set candidate ranked on the ballot.
Woodall's mono-add-top criterion says that adding ballots,
each with candidate A strictly preferred to every other candidate,
must not change the winner from candidate A to some other candidate.
To the best of my knowledge, there is no election method that
has been proven to satisfy the Smith criterion and mono-add-top.
Markus Schulze
Hallo,
> I suspect that a Condorcet method exists (e.g. any ISDA method)
> which can only fail participation when the winner is not the
> first Smith-set candidate ranked on the ballot.
Woodall's mono-add-top criterion says that adding ballots,
each with candidate A strictly preferred to every other candidate,
must not change the winner from candidate A to some other candidate.
To the best of my knowledge, there is no election method that
has been proven to satisfy the Smith criterion and mono-add-top.
Markus Schulze