election-methods@mailman.electorama.com

Technical discussion of election methods

View all threads

POLL again: Approaching deadline: 2024-05-16 05:15:00 UTC

KM
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
Wed, May 15, 2024 5:46 PM

That's 11 and a half hours from now.

So if you have a ballot that's almost done, or feel like submitting one,
now would be the time :-)

CLC: Since I don't know the WDSC status of every Condorcet method in
this poll, I suggest we count the ballot so that every WDSC Smith method
mentioned on list since I last asked are ranked in the WDSC category,
and every other Smith method below it, even if strictly speaking some of
them may pass WDSC. If you want it to be counted differently, let me or
Michael know within the deadline.

-km

That's 11 and a half hours from now. So if you have a ballot that's almost done, or feel like submitting one, now would be the time :-) CLC: Since I don't know the WDSC status of every Condorcet method in this poll, I suggest we count the ballot so that every WDSC Smith method mentioned on list since I last asked are ranked in the WDSC category, and every other Smith method below it, even if strictly speaking some of them may pass WDSC. If you want it to be counted differently, let me or Michael know within the deadline. -km
MG
Michael Garman
Wed, May 15, 2024 5:54 PM

I propose a five day extension.

On Wed, May 15, 2024 at 7:47 PM Kristofer Munsterhjelm km_elmet@t-online.de
wrote:

That's 11 and a half hours from now.

So if you have a ballot that's almost done, or feel like submitting one,
now would be the time :-)

CLC: Since I don't know the WDSC status of every Condorcet method in
this poll, I suggest we count the ballot so that every WDSC Smith method
mentioned on list since I last asked are ranked in the WDSC category,
and every other Smith method below it, even if strictly speaking some of
them may pass WDSC. If you want it to be counted differently, let me or
Michael know within the deadline.

-km

Election-Methods mailing list - see https://electorama.com/em for list
info

I propose a five day extension. On Wed, May 15, 2024 at 7:47 PM Kristofer Munsterhjelm <km_elmet@t-online.de> wrote: > That's 11 and a half hours from now. > > So if you have a ballot that's almost done, or feel like submitting one, > now would be the time :-) > > CLC: Since I don't know the WDSC status of every Condorcet method in > this poll, I suggest we count the ballot so that every WDSC Smith method > mentioned on list since I last asked are ranked in the WDSC category, > and every other Smith method below it, even if strictly speaking some of > them may pass WDSC. If you want it to be counted differently, let me or > Michael know within the deadline. > > -km > ---- > Election-Methods mailing list - see https://electorama.com/em for list > info >
FE
Filip Ejlak
Wed, May 15, 2024 9:31 PM

My ballot (some choices were tough):

  1. Benham
  2. Schwartz-Woodall
  3. Woodall
  4. Ranked Pairs
  5. Schulze
  6. Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
  7. MinMax
  8. Raynaud
  9. Baldwin
  10. RCIPE
  11. IRV
    ------ approval cutoff ------
  12. Smith//DAC
  13. Margin-Sorted Min(LV)
  14. Margin-Sorted Approval
  15. Smith//Approval (explicit)
  16. Smith//Approval (implicit)
  17. Smith//Score
  18. Double Defeat, Hare
  19. Copeland//Borda
  20. Black
  21. Approval
  22. Majority Judgement
  23. Score
  24. Approval with runoff
  25. STAR
  26. Plurality
  27. Borda

śr., 15 maj 2024, 19:47 użytkownik Kristofer Munsterhjelm <
km_elmet@t-online.de> napisał:

That's 11 and a half hours from now.

So if you have a ballot that's almost done, or feel like submitting one,
now would be the time :-)

CLC: Since I don't know the WDSC status of every Condorcet method in
this poll, I suggest we count the ballot so that every WDSC Smith method
mentioned on list since I last asked are ranked in the WDSC category,
and every other Smith method below it, even if strictly speaking some of
them may pass WDSC. If you want it to be counted differently, let me or
Michael know within the deadline.

-km

Election-Methods mailing list - see https://electorama.com/em for list
info

My ballot (some choices were tough): 1. Benham 2. Schwartz-Woodall 3. Woodall 4. Ranked Pairs 5. Schulze 6. Max Strength Transitive Beatpath 7. MinMax 8. Raynaud 9. Baldwin 10. RCIPE 11. IRV ------ approval cutoff ------ 12. Smith//DAC 13. Margin-Sorted Min(LV) 14. Margin-Sorted Approval 15. Smith//Approval (explicit) 16. Smith//Approval (implicit) 17. Smith//Score 18. Double Defeat, Hare 19. Copeland//Borda 20. Black 21. Approval 22. Majority Judgement 23. Score 24. Approval with runoff 25. STAR 26. Plurality 27. Borda śr., 15 maj 2024, 19:47 użytkownik Kristofer Munsterhjelm < km_elmet@t-online.de> napisał: > That's 11 and a half hours from now. > > So if you have a ballot that's almost done, or feel like submitting one, > now would be the time :-) > > CLC: Since I don't know the WDSC status of every Condorcet method in > this poll, I suggest we count the ballot so that every WDSC Smith method > mentioned on list since I last asked are ranked in the WDSC category, > and every other Smith method below it, even if strictly speaking some of > them may pass WDSC. If you want it to be counted differently, let me or > Michael know within the deadline. > > -km > ---- > Election-Methods mailing list - see https://electorama.com/em for list > info >