election-methods@mailman.electorama.com

Technical discussion of election methods

View all threads

Smith//NEO & Smith//MMPO

MO
Michael Ossipoff
Mon, Sep 19, 2016 6:29 AM

Smith//NEO would be a lot easier to implement than Plain NEO.

NEO as the Condorcet completion method, instead of by itself.

Smith// MMPO trades FBC for Smith. Not a bad trade, because you'd use a
rank method for when people want or need to rank.

Also, would avoid the bad- example.  ...&, used with fewer candidates,
there's less scope for other bad-examples.

Michael Ossipoff

Smith//NEO would be a lot easier to implement than Plain NEO. NEO as the Condorcet completion method, instead of by itself. Smith// MMPO trades FBC for Smith. Not a bad trade, because you'd use a rank method for when people want or need to rank. Also, would avoid the bad- example. ...&, used with fewer candidates, there's less scope for other bad-examples. Michael Ossipoff